| Subject: OPINION DIGEST: "Virginia Anti-Bullying Bills," "Bully Teacher," "Dealing with Bullies," "SC Surveys LGBT Community," "Bullying Gets Better?," "Glee's Gay Suicide," "Are You the One?" |
| From: "Brad A Palmertree" <Brad@safeschoolscoalition.org> |
| Date: Thu, 20 Jan 2011 02:32:08 -0500 |
| To: NEWS@safeschoolscoalition.org |
Dear Safe Schools Coalition Members and Friends:
(1) “Two Virginia Lawmakers Introduce Anti-Bullying Bills”
(2) “When The Teacher is the Bully”
(3) “Four Ways to Deal with a Bully
Situation at School”
(4) “SC Equality Publishes Monumental
Study of State’s LGBT Community”
(5) “Does Bullying Really Get Better?”
(6) “Glee’s Gay Suicide PSA: It Got
Worse”
(7) “Bullying: Are You The One?”
***************************************
(1) “Two Virginia Lawmakers Introduce
Anti-Bullying Bills”
http://www.bilerico.com/2011/01/two_virginia_lawmakers_introduce_anti-bullying_bil.php
As I have written
before here and here, Virginia's current anti-bullying laws are nothing less
than a joke and school personnel who fail to address bullying are pretty much
given blanket immunity while the bullies face virtually no consequences - even
when the bullying leads to a student's suicide as happened last May at Grafton
High School in nearby York County in the case of Christian Taylor (pictured at
right). In Taylor's case, his principal bully continues to strut around the
school and likely bullies others - still with zero consequences.
Now, two members of
the Virginia General Assembly - one gay and one straight have introduced bills
that would address this shameful deficiency in Virginia's laws.
These bills deserve
passage yet I am sure will be strongly opposed by the Christianists at The
Family Foundation (a Focus on the Family and FRC affiliate) who want no
conceivable constraints on their ability to denigrate and make life a living
hell for LGBT students and others who do not subscribe to their vile and
perverted version of Christianity. One can only hope that all too spineless
members of the General Assembly with for once stand up to Victoria Cobb and her
fellow hate merchants. Here are highlights from the Washington Blade's
coverage:
This article is
continued at http://www.bilerico.com/2011/01/two_virginia_lawmakers_introduce_anti-bullying_bil.php
***************************************
(2) “When The Teacher is the Bully”
http://drdeborahserani.blogspot.com/2011/01/when-teacher-is-bully.html
Bullying has been front and
center in the public arena for some time now. In recent years, schools have
promoted a zero tolerance for schoolyard bullying. Guidelines and resources are
more readily available to cope with the workplace bully, as well as for cyber
bullying that happens on the computer superhighway.
But what if your child's teacher
is the bully? Recent research shows that 2% of children are bullied by a
teacher in their lifetime. Teachers who are bullies have the same
characteristics of other bullies. They are sadistic and petty, gaining
self-esteem through the humiliation of others. In the school environment, a
teacher-bully will shame a child in front of classmates, often using their
position of authority in abusive ways. The teacher-bully may make an example of
a child, sending him out of the room or to the corner. Maybe an extra
assignment or denying your child recess becomes the vehicle for bullying.
I had a teacher who was a bully.
I was in the 10th grade and she made my life miserable. She was my Spanish
teacher, and all year long she picked on me, calling on me to answer impossible
questions, throwing me out of the class for making noise and even accusing me
of cheating on the Regents exam. Luckily, I had a reputation as being a very
quiet student, never getting into any trouble or mischief. I hardly spoke in
class and was painfully shy. Administrators responsible for overseeing my
“discipline” knew there was a bullying situation going on. Unfortunately, there
were two choices. Either drop Spanish and not graduate or stay in the class,
since there were no other Spanish classes to transfer into. The lesser of two
evils was to stay in the class. And though I had support from my parents and
from my friends, the teacher’s bullying was traumatic for me. I was young and
ill-equipped to deal with the humiliation and accusations. Like a deer in
headlights, I just stood there, helpless.
You may read the rest of this
blog, including some tips for dealing with a bully teacher at http://drdeborahserani.blogspot.com/2011/01/when-teacher-is-bully.html
**************************************
(3) “Four Ways to Deal with a Bully
Situation at School”
http://christinejavier.blogspot.com/2011/01/four-ways-to-deal-with-bully-situation.html
***************************************
(4) “SC Equality Publishes Monumental
Study of State’s LGBT Community”
South Carolina Equality, a group
dealing with lgbt education and advocacy in SC, has come out with a monumental
survey of over 1,000 of the state's lgbt community.
According to Q-Notes:
The survey exposes several needs
and challenges currently facing the state’s estimated 117,000 LGBT citizens,
advocates say, particularly among LGBT youth in the state’s public schools.
Nearly half (48 percent) of
respondents indicated they’d experienced bullying, harassment or discrimination
in South Carolina’s public education.
Christine Johnson, head of SC
Equality said that she has already begun conversations with state lawmakers in
order to get the ball rolling on anti-bullying legislation.
However, according to South
Carolina Republican strategist Wesley Donehue, this may be a difficult fight.
Donehue said the following in a piece at ProcessStory.com:
There are many Republicans in the
General Assembly who will flat out try to kill any bill providing more gay
rights. They aren’t the problem for the SC (Equality). Their problem will be
the many forward-thinking Republicans who are sympathetic to their cause, but
won’t go for putting more laws on the books and creating a special protected
class.
Donehue's comments no doubt
leaves many (myself included) bewildered, particularly in light of a
legislative battle which took place last year over a bill regarding teen dating
violence.
To read the rest of this blog,
please visit http://holybulliesandheadlessmonsters.blogspot.com/2011/01/sc-equality-publishes-monumental-study.html
***************************************
(5) “Does Bullying Really Get Better?”
http://neatoday.org/2011/01/19/does-bullying-really-get-better/
High-profile and
heartbreaking incidents of student bullying have happened so frequently in
recent months, especially among gay and lesbian students, that there’s a new
word for the phenomenon: bullicide. And it’s left educators and parents alike
wondering—just what in the world are we doing wrong? How is it some of our
children can be so mean? And others so despairing? Aren’t these anti-bullying
programs, popular in so many schools, working at all?
It’s possible that
what we think we know about bullying isn’t all we need to know — it’s also
possible that some of the most commonly held assumptions are misguided or that
far too many adults still don’t believe bullying is a serious problem.
But finding the right
answers is critical to NEA’s mission of ensuring a quality education for every
student. Bullying robs students of their opportunity to learn and “exacts scars
that can last a lifetime,” notes NEA President Dennis Van Roekel. Its victims
are more likely to fall behind, miss school, and eventually drop out. We owe them more that that. Says Van
Roekel: “It is our shared responsibility to ensure that every child can attend
a safe public school.”
Many bullying programs
apply a one-size-fits-all approach to problems on campus. They train teachers
and support professionals to be watchful and consistent (often at a high
price). But while it’s critically important for every adult on campus to
recognize and stop bullying, Colby College professor Lyn Mikel Brown,
co-director of the nonprofit Hardy Girls, Healthy Women, believes most of these
“top-down” programs look promising, but don’t go far enough.
“You really have to do
this work with students,” Brown says. “Those programs don’t allow for the
messy, on-the-ground work of educating kids. That’s what has to happen and it
looks different in different schools and communities.”
It likely starts with
a needs assessment, going into a school and understanding what are the major
issues. Is it harassment of gay kids? Is it kids with disabilities? Who are the
harassers? Then, Brown says, you have to engage kids in creative ways to work
through those issues: “[R]esponsive classroom work, the work where you have
kids sitting in circles and processing this information. That’s the most
powerful work.”
To read the rest of
this blog, visit this link
http://neatoday.org/2011/01/19/does-bullying-really-get-better/
***************************************
(6) “Glee’s Gay Suicide PSA: It Got
Worse”
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/leah-anthony-libresco/glees-gay-suicide-psa-it_b_781815.html
Popular TV show Glee has had a tendency to go off the rails when it
tackles serious issues. The show's irreverent, ironic tone had led them to
strike occasional false notes when they address issues of disability and
discrimination in the past. Last night's episode, framed as a response to the
rash of gay suicides early this year was extraordinary counterproductive.
When Mr. Schuester, the glee club advisor, sees Kurt being hit by a
member of the football team, the teacher does not discipline the bully himself
or go to the principal's office to make sure the bullying is resolved. He
accepts at face value Kurt's statement that Mr. Schuester can do nothing to help
him. Once Schuester feels like he is off the hook, he reframes the problem as
Kurt's responsibility, asking him why Kurt is "letting it get to you"
and rebuking him for becoming withdrawn and belligerent.
Depression or anger is a reasonable response to abuse. Although Kurt
would probably prefer to be less upset by his bullies, it is unfair for
Schuester to frame Kurt's response as the problem, rather than the abuse
provoking his response.
If Glee had set up Mr. Schuester's response as a reflection of the lapses
of some teachers and districts and had provided a better model later in the
episode, his counterproductive message could have been redeemed. However, the
mistakes of Mr. Schuester were repeated and amplified a few scenes later by the
episode's unambiguous 'good guy.'
Kurt meets Blaine, a gay student at a more tolerant school, and turns to
him for advice. Blaine was also bullied at his old school before he transferred
to his new, zero-tolerance private school. Since private school tuition isn't
an option for Kurt, Blaine tells him he should "refuse to be the
victim."
This advice to gay teens is misleading and dangerous. It is ridiculous to
say that bullied students need to "refuse to be the victim." No one
consents to assault. Kurt is not allowing or condoning bullying because he is
upset by it. No one should feel ashamed that they could not stop a bully on
their own or that they had to withdraw from a painful situation.
To read the rest of this blog,
visit this link http://www.huffingtonpost.com/leah-anthony-libresco/glees-gay-suicide-psa-it_b_781815.html
***************************************
(7) “Bullying: Are You The One?”
qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq
Safe Schools Coalition- - - - - - - - - -
c/o Rosehedge
1401 East Jefferson Street, Suite 401
Seattle, WA 98122
About this Listserv
To SUBSCRIBE to the
Safe Schools Coalition's IMPORTANTNEWS List, which averages 2 messages/week including only: urgent messages,
action items, SSC meeting minutes
To SUBSCRIBE to the Safe Schools Coalition's NEWS
List, which averages
2 messages/day including THOSE SAME
THINGS plus: events
(conferences, courses, rallies, TV specials, activism
opportunities) , resources (books, DVDs, scholarships,
curricula, and more), jobs and volunteer and
internship opportunities, news digests, opinion
digests
To UNSUBSCRIBE or
To SWITCH LISTS (from NEWS to IMPORTANT NEWS or vice
versa) or
To CHANGE YOUR ADDRESS , if you are already a subscriber,
GO TO http://www.safeschoolscoalition.org/listsub.asp
***************************************
The Safe Schools Coalition is a public-private partnership of 60+ organizations (government agencies, schools, community agencies, churches, youth/student groups, gay/lesbian groups, human rights groups) and 100+ individuals working to help schools become safe places where every family can belong, where every educator can teach, and where every child can learn, regardless of gender identity or sexual orientation.
Safe
Schools' website: http://www.safeschoolscoalition.org
Safe Schools' blog: http://safeschoolscoalition.blogspot.com/
Join SSC's group on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=43732067796
Join SSC's group on LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/groups?gid=1110307
Follow SSC on Twitter: http://twitter.com/safeschoolsc
Got a problem at school with
anti-gay harassment?
In Washington State:
1-877-SAFE-SAFE (1-877-723-3723) 24 hours a day - the
phone line is answered at the Sexual Assault Hotline and
they will have a Safe Schools Coalition Intervention
Specialist volunteer get back to you within 24 hours. Or
contact us by email: Intervention: http://www.safeschoolscoalition.org/contact/?id=10
and we will respond within 24 hours.